America is Good because of how it started. Men came from all over all at once and were generally okay with each other. The harsh winters taught them empathy for a new neighbor who wasn't used to the cold. Those who tried to take advantage of their neighbors were simply left to fend for themselves, neither punished nor prized. Those who lamented over their miserable lot in the unforgiving land, those who made sure everyone knew about their ancestor's riches or even their supposed fame in their old countries, and who insisted that they deserved something better, but who then refused to work on account of this supposed status, received little sympathy. The neighborly helping hand went to those who could show they were trying their damnedest.
The northern states didn't start on a foundation of slavery (specifically) and hierarchies (generally), and this old world model of society brought to the South eventually lost out. The northern states, which set the standard for the America of today, were populated with people who didn't see hard work as a representation of poverty, but as the only respectable road to wealth. Americans have always felt a certain disdain for the communities that keep their women in white gloves and try to put on airs, the people who “live like mice in their own kitchens.”*
The Americans that give the country its strength today are the ones who do not evaluate their neighbor's worth based on his parents' name or notoriety, but only on his own acts, because they, too, had seen family members succumb to winters of various shapes and sizes and wish, too, to be judged only on their own merits. Someone becomes successful in America almost never by luck, but by taking the right risks and by embracing the idea of hard work. That means that even the best “breeding” can produce failed adults if that adult makes the wrong decisions, and, likewise, there's no reason to be sure that someone from the wost of beginnings can't eventually make a name for himself. There is a respect for roads less traveled, for those who get what they want in the way that works best for them, even if it takes a little longer or requires a few stops along the way (provided, of course, that this method doesn't require hurting other people in the process).
America is Good because it takes cultural change in stride and it does not hang on to outdated ideas of caste and bloodlines. The first Americans never stopped telling their children of the humility that is gained during a months-long boat ride across an icy sea. The boats have also yet to cease their voyages today, and for this reason the stories stay fresh. America is Good because, even though it can take a little reminding sometimes, Americans never forget each other, and the fact that the happiness of one depends on the happiness of everyone. We always see ourselves in the faces of our neighbors, and this makes it possible for us to grow together.
*A quote from My Ántonia. Have I inspired you to read it yet?
I know this was totally optimistic and idealistic but that's how the book made me feel.

Hi dear That was very patriotic. You didn't inspire me to read it. I felt that we had almost written it. America has been very good to us and like wise I feel we have been good to it. we came over in 1962,with 2 children. Through hard work we have owned 2 nice homes, cars. We have a family, which gets bigger all the time and lots of friends. Grandad owned his own business. and through the 20 yrs of ownership, gave work to 40o+ men and women. You know the story. (and yes, people did say to Grandad
ReplyDeletearen't you lucky. He would always say. Well it's very strange, but the harder I work, the luckier I get) Yes , I must say America has been very good to us. We love it. and God Bless America.
AMERICA IS THE BEST!!!!!
ReplyDeleteBut chances of me reading the book is slim to none. hahahahahah
Now this isn’t a go at Americans but this always annoys me when mentioning America’s beginnings.
ReplyDeleteAmericans must never forget that there were people there before them. Men survived the first winters because of the help given by the Amerindians. Without their help Europeans wouldn’t have known how to plant the unusual vegetables discovered, or hunted for the animals present. It may have been a time of social cohesion but that was partly from the dangers of the natives present that caused such a nuisance. The American constitution and early government is believed to have been modelled, loosely, on the Iroquois confederacy as another example. They have had as much impact on your country as any in the ‘New World’ but are always ignored. Once again I am not criticising America but wanted to make a point about this overlooked aspect of history. Hope I didn’t bore you too much.
Not intended to hamper your optimism at all, but we Americans sure do love to watch our neighbors when they're an entertaining train wreck.
ReplyDeleteGlad you're feeling positive. Nothing like a foreign land to make you miss the positives of home :)
Carlos - Educated Americans most certainly have not forgotten the decimation and tragedies wrought by whitey on the indigenous cultures. That is a separate issue that can in fact be discussed independently of the idealistic puritan beginnings that made the country so strong. We're in a place (after so many years of feeling like the world's pariah) that we finally feel hopeful and excited - despite the economic mess that has been unleashed - so let us crow a little... I swear it seems that Americans can't ever speak highly of their country without someone coming to tell them how wrong and bad they are. I find it especially difficult to swallow knowing that despite everything we are still the model that the rest of the world looks to in terms of environmental issues (we were 30 years ahead of the rest of the world on environmental laws) human rights (gitmo is NOT our legacy), civil rights (brazil can't even begin to compare) and religious tolerance. Don't get me wrong, I'm the first to criticize my country when I think we're misbehaving, but I get defensive when it comes from elsewhere because, as the saying goes, he who lives in glass houses...
ReplyDeleteDanielle - you did inspire me to read it! Also, I was feeling very similarly recently after reading/listening to this.
http://travel.nytimes.com/2009/03/08/travel/08amtrak.html?ref=travel
Saudades... hugh? I gotta make that trip someday!
The only point i was making was that the origins of America are romanticised and it was not a peaceful and happy time for all.I did not criticise modern America, but I do not agree that you are never allowed to say how great your country is. Have you seen a Hollywood film recently? I'm English and know many Americans and have family there. I'm constantly being bombarded with how how great America is and how rubbish England is. I've had this in Brazil,Malaysia, all of europe,etc from Americans and have to say you must be one of the most overally patriotic countries in the world. I enjoy both of your blogs very much, btw.
ReplyDelete