So recently, Alexandre had to go to the illustrious city of Cubatão for some work stuff. I know that Alex from Bossa Breezes is familiar with it, but for those of you who have never heard of it, you're missing out! It's a real gem. You know, a testament to the industrial revolution. Go ahead and do a Google Images search to see how pristine and clean it is. It's famous for being one of the most polluted cities in the world, so much so that babies started being born without brains. (Read more of the fun on Wikipedia.) Supposedly it's better now, but I've driven through it. It's not pretty.
Anyway, Alexandre was handed an anti-abortion flyer from someone from "the Association in Defense of the Source of Life and Family". From Cubatão. I FIND THIS EXTREMELY IRONIC.
I'll let you bask in that irony for a bit.
Now I'm going to show you the flyer, which Alexandre saved for the specific purpose of my sharing it with all of you. (He's so good to us!)
Here it is, in all its glory:
I don't want to translate all of it; I think the pictures are really what make the flyer what it is. Notice the tiny little baby in the adult man's hands at the top. And then there's the tiny little baby under the side that says "VIDA SIM!" (Yes to life!).
Above it, it says, "the baby's tiny little heart starts beating at approximately 20 days." Then, the baby, which apparently can already crawl in the mother's uterus, says, "I'm completely formed, but I have to wait until it's time to be born!" This is the baby's status at the 12-week mark, according to the flyer. (Damn, I thought I was a cool baby for walking at 9 months, and for thinking at 1 year!)
Then there's the little fetus crying. It says, "I'm innocent, and I've been condemned to death. I can't cry. I can't run. I can't call for help. Won't you do anything to defend me?"
Then, under the part that says "ABORTO NÃO!" (No to abortion!), the pictures of how abortion happens are even better.
I mean, look at that one of the baby getting sucked out of the uterus and broken up into tiny bits. Look at its little face of panic!
And when the abortion occurs through "curreting" (#2), it seems as though the baby's suffering face is left for last, and the baby can still feel pain, even when the rest of its body has been chopped up.
Oh yes, and apparently, babies cry when they're aborted. And according to type of abortion #3, which is "a c-section to kill the baby," "sometimes, the baby comes out still alive and is murdered afterwards."
I don't want this post to turn into a debate on abortion. I think my opinion is pretty clear here, and that's not the point. My first point of this post is to entertain you with the flyer's over-the-top nature. My second point is that this flyer is ineffective, because the few people whose sympathies would be swayed by a flyer like this (evangelical grandmothers) are already against abortion. I doubt that this misinformation and this oversimplified attempt to humanize a fetus are going to convince anyone new to join the pro-life movement. Try appealing to my intelligence rather than drawing and photocopying cartoons, ya know? I mean, try telling me something logical, rather than insisting, "but the poor little wittle baby's little wittle heart is beating and the wittle baby's gonna just be so saaaaad!"
Um, also, Cubatão? You're anti-abortion? Really? Because forcing all babies to come to full term has proven wildly successful for you in the past...?
One more point: Abortion's already illegal in Brazil, so this flyer is moot. Shouldn't the other side be the one making the flyers? I'll bet I'd be able to find some nice and gruesome pictures from this "Valley of Death" showing what happens when a woman isn't allowed to get an abortion, even if doctors know early on that her baby is going to look like this. Because that's the law right now in Brazil, and that's much scarier than anything this Christian cartoonist could think up.
I'll go ahead and publish all of your comments on this one! Just know that if you try to use my blog comments section as your soapbox, it's going to be about as effective as this flyer was on me. If you're offended, then please, by all means, call up the organization in Cubatão to offer your support, and stop reading my blog.
Thursday, November 10, 2011
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)






I suspect misinformation is far more effective than we might think. Obviously, intelligent people aren't the target audience. A single flyer may not change anyone's mind, but it serves to reinforce a message presented repeatedly by the church, politicians, opinionated acquaintences and relatives, etc.
ReplyDeleteMore likely, it's to discourage people who already mostly believe abortion should be illegal from veering down the path of "well, maybe it wouldn't be so bad...".
That link needs a NSFL tag. I seriously regret clicking on it.
ReplyDeleteIn other news, I'm 99% positive babies don't have a fully formed heart with heartbeat at 20 days. I could be wrong.
Finally, did you see some of the recent pro-life bills coming up here? One just failed (and not by a large margin) in Mississippi yesterday that would declare cells personhood at FERTILIZATION, and would even outlaw some forms of birth control. Yikes.
With Abortion already being illegal, don't you think they should have made babies without brains are bad flyers?
ReplyDeleteMore affective.
"The poor baby can't cry, the baby has no motor reflexes, poor baby has no brains! Who will defend the brainless babies! Pollution is BAD!
Yikes! There are brainless babies born in Paulinia too. My neighbor terminated a pregnancy at 7 months because the baby didn't have brains. Scares the sh*t out of me right now.
Aww Danielle, yes! Cubatao holds a special place in my heart. Well my heart that wasn't originally there when I was born in Cubatao in 1992. I'm loving that irony too btw.
ReplyDeleteAnywho, I literally starting laughing out loud (probably should not have) when looking at those illustrations. Nothing sums up my feelings better than...Que Horror.
Anyway, thanks for the shout out and next time something about birds comes up in my blog I'm totally tagging you.
Abracos,
Alex
Have you ever been to a Bodies Exhibit? Basically people donate their bodies to science and are displayed. Check out their website for more info: http://www.bodiestheexhibition.com/about-the-exhibition.html
ReplyDeleteAnyway. My point is that you might find less humor and more compassion after seeing a dead fetus at various stages. Surprisingly more child like than you would think and I actually cried in the exhibit.
That and the fact that the genetic combination can never be recreated lead me feel such sorrow for abortions.
I also want to add that I have seen a several 20wk deaths (NICU RN) and although they are not compatible with life at that age I don't feel that anyone should be able to just throw a baby away. :(
Although illegal in Brazil it still happens and I wish that women had the environment to do it in a safe place. I also wish for stricter restrictions and more education on the matter. This poster obviously doesn't do very much for education....
Sara
I always laugh when I see anti-abortion ads here in Brazil. Is there really a chance Brazil is going to be pro-choice in the near future??? Probably not! Thanks for the entertaining flyer.
ReplyDeleteKudos to Alexandre for saving the flyer!
ReplyDelete@SN I would dispute that people donate their bodies willingly to the Bodies Exhibition. The company putting on the exhibition couldn't very whether the bodies were those of executed criminals. There were protests in Dublin outside it. Quite like this..
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gT9xuXQjxMM
I want to go to the bodies exhibit!!
ReplyDeleteWow. That flyer is something else. Of course, Brazilian women were the ones who figured out how to use some prescription med for an abortion (which has since been taken off the market.) in the 1980's.
ReplyDeleteBack in the US, I was at a Brazilian party when I was married for about a month, when someone said she was against abortion. Without thinking I said "then don't have one." I didn't realize it was still illegal here and how vehement many people are about it!
I'm more concerned about the right to choose. Forced sterilization is still happening in Brazil- Manaus I think- and has been inflicted on mainly women of color in both the US and here. Disturbing stuff. "Hey- you're poor, an Indian or Black, so no kids for you!"
PG is correct. The bodies exhibit consists of unclaimed bodies from the Chinese government. Most of them are thought to have been executed prisoners. I thought the exhibit was very interesting, but the way they were acquired is creepy.
ReplyDeleteReally! I had no idea about the Bodies exhibit! That's so wrong but still very interesting. Learn something everyday :)
ReplyDeleteAccording to the wikipedia link the company also claims that all the fetuses died from miscarriages but it really makes you wonder now...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bodies:_The_Exhibition
Sara
At UCI they had these people on campus with signs showing horrible fake pictures of full-grown babies, I'm assuming miniaturized, and covered in blood and stuff to show what a baby looks like when you abort it at a certain number of weeks. (There's a whole shitload of them on the internet if you search for 'em.)
ReplyDeleteAlso, I think you're missing the point when you want them to try to reason with you with intelligence... most movements that take away other human beings' rights don't have to do with reason and logic, which is the whole reason they work.
I can understand how people can be against abortion, but I can´t understand why they can be so mean to women who decide towards it. I´ve heard so much about nurses who are mean to women who perform a illegal abortion and need to rush to the hospital. When I was 15, a colleague from school who were 17 died because her boyfriend took her to an illegal clinic, she had a internal bleeding and died. I think woman would never think something as "Ok, so I´m going to get pregnant just to have an abortion, that´s so much fun!". Once I supported a friend who had to make this decision, it´s not easy at all, and she was lucky that a friend of hers gave her the money and so she could go to a 'fancy' and proper place. She cried a lot, thought a lot about that, but she could go to a safe place. Many women all around the country just use knitting needle buy Citotec on the black market, or inhale the vapour from boiling "buxinha", and so many lose her life every year. Not fair.
ReplyDeleteSo sorry about my English mistakes, I only saw it after publishing it :(.
ReplyDeleteAbortion is illegal in Brazil?
ReplyDeleteWell, I shouldn't be so shocked. I can't really think of a majority-Catholic country outside of the EU that has legalised abortion.
I'm just interested that a country with such an open constitution when it comes to other sensitive stuff like gay rights could be so old-fashioned on this one.
Well, you learn something new every day.
Oy. Is this still what people will stoop to? No matter how many times they try, it's impossible to make abortion illegal. If a woman wants to have an abortion she will find a way to have one. No matter what these moral crusaders say, a woman has the right to access, for her own safety. Jeez. I would have been enraged if I saw this flyer on the street.
ReplyDeleteIt seems that an attempt to allow abortion in cases of extreme fetal abnormalities is going through the courts; according to Wikipedia, a judge had ruled that anencephalic pregnancies could be terminated, then his decision was overruled. Regardless of a position pro or con on abortion, Brazil's legal stance (and sentences) are grossly out of step with science and humane practices, for both mother and baby. Some of the punishments meted out, and the way that women are hunted down when a supposed abortion doctor is outed, are simply medieval. And in the case of a pregnancy that is clearly not viable, why should a woman be forced to carry it until it causes a risk to her own life?
ReplyDeleteAnd so with you on the flyer. Was it produced by a foreign group that didn't realize it's already illegal in Brazil????
Don't kill the babies!!!!
ReplyDeleteClarification: Abortion is illegal in Brazil except for
ReplyDeletea) risk of death for the mother -- if a doctor says "this is a high risk pregnancy, mother will probably die" then she can have an abortion if she chooses so.
b) the pregnancy resulted from a rape -- again, the mother may choose to abort
When there is extreme fetus malformation, the mother may require an special authorization to make the abortion. This is done via judicial process and the result may depend on the opinion of the judge ( http://www.ufrgs.br/bioetica/abortobr.htm )
There's a link circulating in Facebook about a proposed law from 2007 that would make illegal any kind of abortion. You should read the interview with the proponent, as it's full of gems like "it's proved that mothers tend to love the children resulting from rape, as mothers love better the kids that gave them more trouble".
This project is linked to another that would make illegal any kind of assisted reproduction. Sadly, none has yet been discarded. ( http://www.estadao.com.br/noticias/impresso,projeto-de-lei-cria-bolsa-estupro-para-evitar-que-mulheres-abortem,95241,0.htm )
Kzk,
ReplyDeleteThe only reason that I've heard be used here in Brazil for a woman to be allowed to have an abortion is the first one (risk to the mother's life).
When a woman is pregnant as the result of rape, many states require her to "prove" that she was raped (her word is not enough), and local churches often protest the woman's decision in small towns.
Did you hear about this?
http://www.feministe.us/blog/archives/2009/03/06/catholic-church-excommunicates-mother-and-doctors-over-9-year-old-rape-victims-abortion/
This country has a long, long way to go in terms of women's rights.